| | |
| Author | Message |
|---|
Marlon Successor


Number of posts: 531 Age: 30 Location: Finland Registration date: 2007-09-04
Character sheet Age: 18
 | Subject: Champion Fri Sep 07, 2007 10:50 am | |
| Gonna, write something about the champions, THE REAL CORE of the fellowships  Copy-pasted from the MIck article and changed it more suitable for champions  Marlon Harefield, a champion of Bree-land, , at your service. I´ve reached level 50 about a month ago and don´t have the same experience about the game in general as Mick has. But I´m better player in any other way than he is So these thoughts of mine are based on my own experinces and should NOT be concidered as the only truth. Attributes. To put it plane and simple, no attribute should be overlooked with a champion either, with the exepction of Fate. Can´t really find that one uselful in any way to the champions. (maybe for soloing ones, because of the out-of combat morale regen) . Vitality ain´t that important either, at least for champions who enjoy the benefits of fellowship-questing. For soloing champions vitality is an attribute that shouldn´t be too much overlooked. In my opinnion the most important attributes for champion are might and will. Might causes you to make some serious constant damage, which is at the end of the day, the main purpouse for the champions existance. Will on the other hand increases champions maximum power, which is very important thing. A champion who´s power has run out in a battle is as important as christmas tree in the summertime. Agility, of course, increases champions chances to deal critical hits. One might want to think wether it is better to hit hard with most of his hits (might) or get some critical hits now and then (agility). I myself have concentrated mainly on might. Will and Agilty come second and vitality the third. I have overlooked fate totally. Gear. Naturally heavy armour is the armour class for the champions. But once again, for the champions constantly doing fellowships with guardians in them, one might want to think the importance of the stats of armour instead of the armour value. So if you have to choose between medium armour gloves with far better attribute stats and heavy armour ones with higher armour value but lower stats, you should really think of choosing the first one. The ideal situation naturally is to find heavy armour gear with good stats. Weapon. I´m not that familiar with the different damage types and stuff like that. But one thing I can and will poin out. Dual wielding is the thing for the champions. Definately. Some of the skills Champions acquires at the mid- and high levels are uselful only with dual wield. At the lower levels it´s a matter of personal taste wether you use dual wield or 2-h weapon. Naturally 2 x 1h-weapon gives better attribute stats though. Virtues. As Mick already mentioned in his Captain topic this really is a matter of personal taste. Naturally it would be nice to go with the ones giving bonuses to the right attributes. Class traits. This really depends wether you are up for AOEing or just dealing major single hits. AS above matter of taste really. Legendary traits. Haven´t completed the Champion quests yet, so can´t say too much about those traits yet. Though the controlling burn-trait appears to increase damage and power recovery, which is always welcome. As for the traits acquired from the books, only one of them is useful. Fericious strikes it is called. The other two seem to be pure and simple rubbish. Tactics. Nothing special in here really. Though one might want to keep in mind that Champion really CANNOT stand that much damage as guardians do. So think it over very carefully wether you want to attack more than 2 mobs at the time. As champions crowd-control skills are next to non-existant, a brave champion charging alone in the middle of crowd of mobs is a dead champion in many cases. 2 mobs of the same level as champion should cause no signifcant problems let alone 1. Champion has 6 different single attack skills (5, depending on the traits) Champion doesn´t deal the biggest damage with his first, second or not even with third of his blows. So don´t get impantient and smack the foes with the skills dealing the lesser damage. There is this thing called fervour (This could be compared to Rage in WOW). There more Champion gets excited in the heat of the battle, the more powerful blows he is able to deal. So don´t go waisting all of the fervour on lower damage blows.( 2 lowest ones, Wild Attack and Swift Strike, in fact add the fervour, so keep hitting with them untill the fervour goes up.) Let it grow and enjoy the reasults. In the fellowships, champion is usually the main-assist and the main damage dealer. Champion can act as emergency tank aswell, but even though champion has quite good variety of aggro-management skills it isn´t wise to act as the main tank. First of all the impressive amount of damage the champion is capable of dealing goes all to waste while tanking and secondly and more importantly, champions cannot stand that much damage compared to guardians. Champion is very usable in kicking the shit out of adds while Guardian is keeping the boss busy. And thus keeping the minstrel´s arse unspoilled. But in general keeping the minstrel safe isn´t the main task for champion. Once again the full benefit of champions damage dealing goes to waste in doing this. There are better classes for protecting the Minstrel. AOE´ing in fellowships is advicable only while dealing with normal mobs. When elites or such are concerned AOE´ing is something that is DEFINATELY out of the question. A hot headed warrior swinging his AOE-skills around while surrounded by elite mobs is the second easiest way of getting the entire fellowship dead. Can´t even be bothered to explain why, but if you are interested in finding the reason, go ahead try it out. Just don´t say you weren´t warned. (oh, the easiest way? didn´t you quess already? AOE´ing hunter, ring any bells?  )
Last edited by on Mon Sep 17, 2007 8:05 am; edited 2 times in total |
|  | | Mick Administrator


Number of posts: 384 Age: 28 Location: Finland Registration date: 2007-09-04
 | Subject: Re: Champion Fri Sep 07, 2007 1:11 pm | |
| | Marlon wrote: | | To put it plane and simple, no attribute should be overlooked with a champion either, with the exepction of Fate. Can´t really find that one uselful in any way to the champions. (maybe for soloing ones, because of the out-of combat morale regen) . |
Is I understand Fate adds in-combat morale and in-combat power regeneration (and tactical crits), as vitality adds for out-of combat morale reg (and morale and various resists). Is this different for champs in some way? I know Fervour adds in-combat morale reg, but other than that... _________________ Playing Lotro is like making love to a beautiful woman; you enter with the state of mind that patience and determination are the virtues here, but after some ferocious efforts you realize that the time spent has been in vain.
|
|  | | Marlon Successor


Number of posts: 531 Age: 30 Location: Finland Registration date: 2007-09-04
Character sheet Age: 18
 | Subject: Re: Champion Mon Sep 17, 2007 8:27 am | |
| | Marlon wrote: | In the fellowships, champion is usually the main-assist and the main damage dealer. |
Yesterday we did learn this the hard way while adventuring in Urugarth. This is how it should and must be..champion should be the one who is targeting the mobs and the others need to follow him. If everyone starts to attack mobs of their own choose, it could easily turn into the plain and simple chaos. The tank can´t hold the aggro of the mobs, while everyone is fireing little bit here and little bit there and the damage dealt to those adds isn´t that good when everyone is attacking mob of their own.
The order of the targeting for the champs is quite simple...non-elites first, sig, elites. etc... though there are times when champ might have to turn the attention of ranged mobs on himself and allow the minstrels concentrate on keeping the tank alive. In fact the ranged mobs are the top priority. They should be taken care of first, if possible. Good way for champion to do this is to use his shouts and with the help of landscape(rocks, walls, etc etc) draw the mob into a melee fight.
It could happen, and it will, at times that champions targerting doesn´t go exactly by the book. But if it doesn´t go totally bonkers, it definately is easiest that everyone else follows the champion instead of taking the decision in their own hands. One thing though that is essential when targeting is concerned, is the communication between the stunners and the champion..no burglar/lore-master/hunter likes to see the mob they have just managed to get stunned attacked by the cahmpion. And no champion likes to get his target feared while trying to beat living **** out of it.
| Marlon wrote: | AOE´ing in fellowships is advicable only while dealing with normal mobs. When elites or such are concerned AOE´ing is something that is DEFINATELY out of the question. A hot headed warrior swinging his AOE-skills around while surrounded by elite mobs is the second easiest way of getting the entire fellowship dead. Can´t even be bothered to explain why, but if you are interested in finding the reason, go ahead try it out. Just don´t say you weren´t warned. (oh, the easiest way? didn´t you quess already? AOE´ing hunter, ring any bells? ) |
Had the "privilege" of witnessing these things in practice yesterday aswell. I´m talking about the aoe´ing (not by a champ though) and the hunters messing it all up for the fellowship.
Don´t you just love it when the hunter is far too trigger happy or taking care of the pulling the mobs with his own decision? Result commonly is that the mob(s) runs past the tank and the other group straight at the hunter which them fears the lot, thus avoiding to get himself hit , and resulting the mobs running around the neighborhood and the tank and the melees unable the hit the bastards or able to get any control of them what so ever. Nice wouldn´t you agree?
Had the pleasure of witnessing a hunter and a minstrel(not Fallen Renegades neither of them, naturally ) causing some real havoc with aoe last night too..the result? entire fellowship dead in just few seconds. Luckily enough the people in question with the later occasion where smart enough to learn from their mistakes and it went quite smoothly towards the end.  _________________ Burn the women, rape the houses!
|
|  | | Mick Administrator


Number of posts: 384 Age: 28 Location: Finland Registration date: 2007-09-04
 | Subject: Re: Champion Mon Sep 17, 2007 9:48 am | |
| Yea. Quite an experience yesterday. Prime example why main assist (MA) is so important. The hunter said when we started that he had been in vacation for the last 3 months, not playing. Maybe that should have told us something. I don't wanna bash all hunters, cause not all are the same, but if you wanna ruin it for the group... that's the way to go. Executing solo-tactics in fellowship. I don't wanna seem like I know everything (which I of course do), but the tank too was a bit lost. Pulling constantly with the bow was a bad choise in my opinion. I cannot stress this enough.. a tank needs to get the aggro of all mobs. He just has to trust that he will be healed. The concentrated DPS will pull the one mob away, but only the one. Rain of Arrows and other AoE ruins it all. 100 % certain. When the tank is trying to get all aggro, others should even wait the couple of seconds for him to get the aggro. If you're not familiar with these tactics, it seems stupid, I know. But there is a point: organizing what otherwise is a chaos. There are few things more annoying than for the hunter (or anyone else for that matter), to shoot as many mobs as they can with high damage. Mobs run past the tank... and control is gone. Like it says in the forums and elsewhere with in more detail.. tank aggroes everything, minstrel heals tank, MA (usually the champion) organizes the killing-order, everyone else assist MA. Yes, there is crowd control and other responsibilities too, but in a nutshell, that's it. I don't wanna sound like a kiss-ass here, but Taera is one of the best minstrels out there. Focus in healing. Know your role. | Marlon wrote: | | One thing though that is essential when targeting is concerned, is the communication between the stunners and the champion |
And communication in general. Between the tank and the stunners is highly important too. Marlon already explained the squashing-order there... the stunners should stun the strongest (or ranged) mobs, and MA should start from the weakest (or ranged) mobs. Tank keeps all others in his grasp. TALK TALK TALK! _________________ Playing Lotro is like making love to a beautiful woman; you enter with the state of mind that patience and determination are the virtues here, but after some ferocious efforts you realize that the time spent has been in vain.
Last edited by on Mon Sep 17, 2007 10:09 am; edited 3 times in total |
|  | | Marlon Successor


Number of posts: 531 Age: 30 Location: Finland Registration date: 2007-09-04
Character sheet Age: 18
 | |  | | Mick Administrator


Number of posts: 384 Age: 28 Location: Finland Registration date: 2007-09-04
 | Subject: Re: Champion Mon Sep 17, 2007 3:57 pm | |
| Not wanting to do the old compare to the unmentionable game, but I remember Marlon saying, when he was like level 30ish, something like: "this game is easier than WoW, in the sense that people don't have to do a flawless job to be succesful in group play". Still thinking like that?  Dying 10 times in one day really takes it out of ya. For the record, I never played WoW. So I can't compare. _________________ Playing Lotro is like making love to a beautiful woman; you enter with the state of mind that patience and determination are the virtues here, but after some ferocious efforts you realize that the time spent has been in vain.
|
|  | | Marlon Successor


Number of posts: 531 Age: 30 Location: Finland Registration date: 2007-09-04
Character sheet Age: 18
 | Subject: Re: Champion Mon Sep 17, 2007 5:31 pm | |
| | Mick wrote: | Not wanting to do the old compare to the unmentionable game, but I remember Marlon saying, when he was like level 30ish, something like: "this game is easier than WoW, in the sense that people don't have to do a flawless job to be succesful in group play".
Still thinking like that?  Dying 10 times in one day really takes it out of ya.
For the record, I never played WoW. So I can't compare. |
Fair enough... I´ll try to explain myself a bit... Ok, recently i´ve noticed that there are things that people really should and shouldn´t do. Just reading the few posts above is a good example. But yet, somehow, i feel that this game is much more forgiving than WoW. Ok, at these higher levels even a one mistake could cost dearly, but at the lower and mid levels you don´t get punished from a single mistake.
As in WoW that wasn´t the case at all imho. Have to confess though, that i wasn´t too much into group-questing and doing instnaces in WoW, much more a pvp-maniac. So it might just be that I wasn´t that familiar with all the aspects of group-questing in WoW. One thing that I have been thinking that could make the impression about LOTRO being "easier" in this matter, is the fact that the players in LOTRO are MUCH more easy going that in WoW. There one could get slaughtered verbally after making even a minor mistake. That is a thing that I haven´t run into in LOTRO so far. _________________ Burn the women, rape the houses!
|
|  | | Mick Administrator


Number of posts: 384 Age: 28 Location: Finland Registration date: 2007-09-04
 | Subject: Re: Champion Mon Sep 17, 2007 5:44 pm | |
| Have to agree about the player base. Yesterday when I tried to explain to the fellowship what the goal and the tactics should be, I at the same time realized that I probably come off like a know-it-all dick. I don't like to tell people how they should play their character, especially because I haven't played any other char than the capt, but I felt it would be better to try advise them a little than to continue the smackdown we were getting. And I think it got a little better towards the end. _________________ Playing Lotro is like making love to a beautiful woman; you enter with the state of mind that patience and determination are the virtues here, but after some ferocious efforts you realize that the time spent has been in vain.
|
|  | | Thopor Master


Number of posts: 903 Age: 33 Location: Poland Registration date: 2007-09-04
Character sheet Age: 32
 | Subject: Re: Champion Mon Sep 17, 2007 5:47 pm | |
| | Marlon wrote: | | One thing that I have been thinking that could make the impression about LOTRO being "easier" in this matter, is the fact that the players in LOTRO are MUCH more easy going that in WoW. There one could get slaughtered verbally after making even a minor mistake. That is a thing that I haven´t run into in LOTRO so far. |
I'd say that there are more mature players in LOTRO than in WOW and that's why it is so. _________________ It's Better To Rule In Hell Than Serve In Heaven.
|
|  | | Tigrim Member

Number of posts: 76 Location: Gray Mountains Registration date: 2007-09-17
Character sheet Age: 386
 | Subject: Comments of a young guardian Mon Sep 17, 2007 6:19 pm | |
| Being a guardian myself, it isn't quite my class forum area, but after reading this I'd like to comment a little: | Mick wrote: | | Like it says in the forums and elsewhere with in more detail.. tank aggroes everything, minstrel heals tank, MA (usually the champion) organizes the killing-order, everyone else assist MA. Yes, there is crowd control and other responsibilities too, but in a nutshell, that's it. |
Undoubtely, Mick is right in this, and I happily throw myself on all the bosses upfront (with a healer in my back, please!) while others care for the lesser mobs. But often people seem to think that their DPS (at which a guardian lacks heavily) count more than the durability of the tank (which obviously is what the guardian is designed for). I especially like the idea of the group to wait a few seconds before taking any actions to allow me to gather up some aggro - it's perfect teamwork, though it surely feels odd at first.
Sadly, I often faced the above described mess of (random) fellowship members pulling off mobs from me, so I'd start to run around helplessly to get a smack in at all - what a silly feeling that is, especially knowing that most often it's time to run soon (if you can). The usual reasons for group failures are over-dpsing the tank or shooting random targets. Yet, I have the hope that these kinda problems are mainly due to the 30'ish level I am at, and therefore most players not being experienced in teamwork since it only started to be required rather few levels ago. People seem to have to get used to it, after getting to this level mostly solo.
But there's another most important thing to know about guardians: Most of their special attacks that draw aggro, do somewhat useful damage, stun or recover power, only get enabled after blocking/parrying, so it is most important to have plenty of mobs bashing the guardian for "working" at maximum efficiency.
Besides, at least seeing players at my currently 30'ish level, I learnt to not trust a random healer blindly and found that my way of going for a maximum in-combat regeneration saved my life many times, as it makes a huge difference in longer battles. (And in short battles nobody requires a tank anyways). With such "base healing" I usually am happy doing red mobs with "only" a secondary healer as teampartner, and I only can recommend this kinda setup for tanking, while I consider Might and Vitality as second important attributes on my equipment. |
|  | | Mick Administrator


Number of posts: 384 Age: 28 Location: Finland Registration date: 2007-09-04
 | |  | | Thopor Master


Number of posts: 903 Age: 33 Location: Poland Registration date: 2007-09-04
Character sheet Age: 32
 | |  | | Aleta Member

Number of posts: 142 Age: 17 Location: North Wales, Llandudno (said clan-did-no) Registration date: 2007-09-13
Character sheet Age:
 | Subject: Re: Champion Thu Sep 27, 2007 12:22 am | |
| i always find that when im in a group i always end up as the back up tank incase the guardian is defeated (rare as that is) _________________ when you fight i shall be there when you win i will celebrate with you when all hope fails i shall save you from darkness we will stand together for honour and glory for we are breathrin
|
|  | | Marlon Successor


Number of posts: 531 Age: 30 Location: Finland Registration date: 2007-09-04
Character sheet Age: 18
 | Subject: Re: Champion Thu Sep 27, 2007 10:41 am | |
| | Galatyer wrote: | | i always find that when im in a group i always end up as the back up tank incase the guardian is defeated (rare as that is) |
That is usually the case. Champion can act as a back- up tank quite efficiently. But one might want to wonder why that has happened? Something has gone somewhat horribly wrong at first place if the Guardian gets killed. Following the "main rule" which has been talked over many times does tend to ease everyones job, included champions and there really is NO need for champion to do tanking.
1. Guardian aggros all the mobs and keeps the main focus on the most powerful one. Minstrel keeps healing the tank. 2. After this has happened, champion(not hunter, or anyone else) picks ONE target and everyone else than Tank attacks THIS mob. (someone should be keeping an eye on minstrel, that he/she doesn´t get attacked by ranged mobs and if she does aggro them) 3. Keep doing this till every other mob has died and then focus on the last one.
As mentioned above and in several other palces, this is only the plot in general, but it really works, believe me. No need to act as a back-up tank because guardian has died if this "plan" is followed. Naturally it can go horribly wrong if even one char is ignoring his duties, normally some trigger happy hunter, guardian that isn´t upto his task, melee-minstrel or hot headed champion, but if people are keeping it plain and simple it works very well. _________________ Burn the women, rape the houses!
|
|  | | Tigrim Member

Number of posts: 76 Location: Gray Mountains Registration date: 2007-09-17
Character sheet Age: 386
 | Subject: Re: Champion Thu Sep 27, 2007 10:50 am | |
| Of course what Mick says is correct, but there's also another scenario possible, e.g. in a group with a "spare" champion. This one could easily work as off-tank, aka pulling away a few lesser mobs from the main tank or the softies, incase there's just too many of them for a single tank. (Possibly this was ment with "backup tank"). Since a champion uses heavy armor, with a proper healer in the back, he/she can tank quite okay in average situations. Especially seeing the nice damage amount this is great for crowds of lesser foes. But the lack of a shield and defensive ability will not make a champion last long in tough situations. |
|  | | |
| Page 1 of 3 | Goto page : 1, 2, 3  |
| | Permissions of this forum: | You cannot reply to topics in this forum
| |
| |
| | November 2009 | | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat | Sun |
|---|
| | | | | | | 1 | | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | | 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 | | 30 | | | | | | | Calendar |
|
| Who is Online ? | In total there are 2 users online :: 0 Registered, 0 Hidden and 2 Guests None Most users ever online was 9 on Fri Jul 24, 2009 7:47 am |
| Statistics | We have 62 registered users The newest registered user is Singvald
Our users have posted a total of 3284 messages in 230 subjects
|
|